Ionic 4对比Angular 6（+Material）：面向SSR的PWA选型问询

Hey there! Let’s break down your options based on your current situation and needs for an SSR-focused PWA:

Ionic 4: Promising but Unstable Right Now #

• The Bright Side: Ionic 4’s core pitch is tighter alignment with Angular’s native routing system—this should directly resolve those routing bugs you’ve been dealing with in Ionic 3. It also promises improved PWA support, like better offline caching, performance tweaks, and closer adherence to modern web standards. If you’re already invested in the Ionic ecosystem (and might want to expand to native apps later via Capacitor), this could be a great long-term fit once it stabilizes.
• The Catch: Since there’s no Alpha release available yet, you’re looking at unknown timelines and potential early-stage bugs. If your project has a tight deadline, betting on an unreleased framework version is risky—you might end up stuck waiting for fixes or troubleshooting unexpected issues that slow your progress.

Angular 6 + Material: Stable, SSR-Ready Today #

• The Bright Side: Angular 6 paired with Angular Universal (for SSR) is a rock-solid, battle-tested stack right now. You’ll get full access to Angular’s native routing system—no more custom Ionic routing quirks causing the problems you’ve faced. Material Design components are officially maintained, integrate seamlessly with Angular, and are optimized for web (and PWA) experiences. This setup lets you build an SSR-focused PWA quickly, with a mature ecosystem to support you every step of the way.
• The Catch: You’ll miss out on Ionic’s out-of-the-box mobile-specific features like gesture support, pre-built mobile navigation patterns, and easy native app conversion. If your PWA needs to feel identical to a native mobile app, you’ll have to build or source alternative solutions for those mobile-centric details.

My Recommendation #

• Wait for Ionic 4 only if: You have flexibility in your timeline, and you value retaining Ionic’s mobile-first tools (with plans to go native later). Once it hits a stable release, it should fix your routing headaches while keeping your existing Ionic knowledge relevant.
• Go with Angular 6 + Material if: You need to launch soon, or your PWA is focused primarily on the web experience. This stack eliminates the uncertainty of unreleased software, resolves your routing issues immediately, and gives you a mature SSR setup from day one.

内容的提问来源于stack exchange，提问作者saiy2k