Python状态模式电梯门:如何终止旧线程并启动新线程
电梯门状态模式多线程异常修正方案
问题根因
当前实现的异常来自两个并发流程缺少身份校验,且存在无保护的状态覆写:
- 触发关门流程后,长耗时逻辑在独立线程运行,此时触发开门操作会生成新的状态实例、启动新的开门流程线程
- 旧的关门流程线程没有判断自己是否已经失效,3秒循环结束后会无视当前实际状态,直接把门状态强制赋值为
Closed,冲掉新启动的开门流程的状态 - Python 线程没有安全的强制终止接口,直接硬杀旧线程会导致资源泄漏、状态数据损坏,无法从根本解决问题
实现思路
采用协作式取消机制替代线程强杀:
- 给电梯门对象增加全局流程标识,每次启动新的开/关流程时自增标识值,每个流程启动时记录自己对应的标识
- 流程每执行一步耗时操作,就比对自己的标识和当前全局标识是否一致,如果不一致说明自己已经被新流程顶替,立刻退出,不再执行后续的状态赋值、日志打印操作
- 增加线程互斥锁,所有涉及状态修改、流程标识更新的操作都加锁保护,避免竞态条件
- 移除各状态类里无校验的状态覆写逻辑,所有状态切换都经过校验后再执行
参考修正代码
from time import sleep from pynput import keyboard from threading import Thread, Lock class Open: def __init__(self, door): self.door = door print('\nOpen') def open(self): pass def close(self): self.door.start_closing_process() class Opening: def __init__(self, door): self.door = door print('\nOpening', end='', flush=True) def open(self): pass def close(self): self.door.start_closing_process() class Closed: def __init__(self, door): self.door = door print('\nClosed') def close(self): pass def open(self): self.door.start_opening_process() class Closing: def __init__(self, door): self.door = door print('\nClosing', end='', flush=True) def close(self): pass def open(self): self.door.start_opening_process() class ElevatorDoor: def __init__(self): self.state = Open(self) self._process_id = 0 self._state_lock = Lock() def start_opening_process(self): # 启动新开门流程,更新全局流程标识 current_id = self._process_id + 1 with self._state_lock: self._process_id = current_id self.state = Opening(self) # 独立线程执行耗时的开门模拟逻辑 def run_flow(): for _ in range(3): # 每步校验当前流程是否已经失效 if self._process_id != current_id: return print('.', end='', flush=True) sleep(1) # 流程执行完毕后,再次校验有效性再切换最终状态 if self._process_id == current_id: with self._state_lock: self.state = Open(self) Thread(target=run_flow).start() def start_closing_process(self): current_id = self._process_id + 1 with self._state_lock: self._process_id = current_id self.state = Closing(self) def run_flow(): for _ in range(3): if self._process_id != current_id: return print('.', end='', flush=True) sleep(1) if self._process_id == current_id: with self._state_lock: self.state = Closed(self) Thread(target=run_flow).start() def open(self): self.state.open() def close(self): self.state.close() if __name__ == '__main__': door = ElevatorDoor() def on_press(key): global door if key == keyboard.Key.esc: return False # 退出键盘监听 try: k = key.char # 单字符按键 except Exception: k = key.name # 特殊按键 if k == 'o': door.open() if k == 'c': door.close() listener = keyboard.Listener(on_press=on_press) listener.start() listener.join()
修正后的运行表现
- 任意时间触发新的开门/关门操作,都会立刻让之前运行的旧流程失效,旧流程不会再执行任何状态覆写操作
- 只有完整走完3秒流程、且期间没有新操作打断的流程,才会最终把状态切换到目标值
- 不会出现旧流程在新流程运行中途强行修改状态、打印异常日志的问题
内容的提问来源于stack exchange,提问作者Feulo
相关产品推荐
相关产品推荐

