四未知数四超越方程组求解:MATLAB、Mathematica结果不符预期及正根获取问题
多未知量超越方程跨平台求解遇到的问题
本人尝试求解含4个未知量的4个超越方程,先后在MATLAB与Mathematica平台开展求解工作。
MATLAB平台求解实现(采用vpasolve函数)
对应求解代码如下:
Y1 = 0.02; l1 = 0.0172; syms Y2 Y3 l2 l3; lambda = [0.0713 0.0688 0.0665]; b1 = 0.1170; b3 = 0.1252; t2_1 = (2*pi/lambda(1))*l2; t3_1 = (2*pi/lambda(1))*l3; t2_3 = (2*pi/lambda(3))*l2; t3_3 = (2*pi/lambda(3))*l3; t1_1 = (2*pi/lambda(1))*l1; t1_3 = (2*pi/lambda(3))*l1; eq1 = 2*Y1*tan(t1_1)+Y2*tan(t2_1)+Y3*tan(t3_1)==0; eq2 = 2*Y1*tan(t1_3)+Y2*tan(t2_3)+Y3*tan(t3_3)==0; eq3 = b1== (t1_1*Y1)+(t2_1*(Y2/2)*((sec(t2_1)^2)/(sec(t1_1)^2)))+(t3_1*(Y3/2)*((sec(t3_1)^2)/(sec(t1_1)^2))); eq4 = b3== (t1_3*Y1)+(t2_3*(Y2/2)*((sec(t2_3)^2)/(sec(t1_3)^2)))+(t3_3*(Y3/2)*((sec(t3_3)^2)/(sec(t1_3)^2))); E=[eq1 eq2 eq3 eq4]; S=vpasolve(E,[Y2,Y3,l2,l3]);
Mathematica平台求解实现(采用NMinimize函数)
针对同一组方程编写的求解代码如下:
eqns = {2*Y1*Tan[t11]+Y2*Tan[t21]+Y3*Tan[t31]==0, 2*Y1*Tan[t13]+Y2*Tan[t23]+Y3*Tan[t33]==0, t11*Y1 + t21*(Y2/2)*(Sec[t21]^2/Sec[t11]^2) + t31*(Y3/2)*(Sec[t31]^2/Sec[t11]^2)-b1==0, t13*Y1 + t23*(Y2/2)*(Sec[t23]^2/Sec[t13]^2) + t33*(Y3/2)*(Sec[t33]^2/Sec[t13]^2)-b3==0}; NMinimize[Norm[Map[First, eqns]], {Y2,Y3,l2,l3}]
当前遇到的问题
- 两个平台对同一组方程求解得到的结果不一致,且均不是符合预期的目标解,推测需要更换适配的求解函数,希望能得到相关求解方法的指导。
- 后续调整参数后尝试求解,可得到方程根,但仅需要正根,此前尝试用于提取正根的方法无法在该场景下生效,暂未排查到具体原因。
参数调整后的补充求解代码
对应补充场景的代码如下:
Y1=0.0125; l1=0.010563; lambda={0.0426,0.0401,0.0403,0.0423,0.0413}; b1 = 0.0804; b3 = 0.0258; t2_1 = (2*Pi/lambda[[1]])*l2; t3_1 = (2*Pi/lambda[[1]])*l3; t2_3 = (2*Pi/lambda[[5]])*l2; t3_3 = (2*Pi/lambda[[5]])*l3; t1_1 = (2*Pi/lambda[[1]])*l1; t1_3 = (2*Pi/lambda[[5]])*l1; eqns = {2*Y1*Tan[t11]+Y2*Tan[t21]+Y3*Tan[t31]==0, 2*Y1*Tan[t13]+Y2*Tan[t23]+Y3*Tan[t33]==0, t11*Y1 + t21*(Y2/2)*(Sec[t21]^2/Sec[t11]^2) + t31*(Y3/2)*(Sec[t31]^2/Sec[t11]^2)-b1==0, t13*Y1 + t23*(Y2/2)*(Sec[t23]^2/Sec[t13]^2) + t33*(Y3/2)*(Sec[t33]^2/Sec[t13]^2)-b3==0};
内容的提问来源于stack exchange,提问作者sunanda
相关产品推荐
相关产品推荐

